A short while ago I was asked to write a blog as a newly qualified Human Factors in Diving Instructor. We talked about a subject and all seemed ok. But try as I might, I just could not explain the topic as eloquently as I wanted. So, we had another chat and I tried a different theme. Same result. The problem was that no matter what I wrote, I just didn’t feel it matched up to what others had written. And that’s when it hit me- I was out Human-Factoring myself.
I’ve been instructing various sports for twenty years and consider myself to be a capable and cautious instructor. I’ve been teaching diving for ten years, so you think by now I’d be quite happy with my level of knowledge. But that’s the thing; almost every time I step foot into the classroom, I’m waiting for someone to call me out, to realise that I actually don’t have clue what I’m talking about and I don’t know anywhere near enough about the subject. As a new instructor for Human Factors, I’m feeling this especially keenly now. When I told my friend this he pointed out that I still know far more than my students and if I did get any questions I didn’t know the answer too I could fall back on my usual habit of telling the student I didn’t know and that I’d find out for them (which usually works well as it forces me to research the subject I didn’t know). I was still worried though. As a student learning about Human Factors, everything had seemed obvious, almost common-sense. Surely my students would feel the same thing? And that’s part of the problem with explaining to people why they need to learn about Human Factors, some people do indeed just see it as common-sense stuff, so why should they learn it?
And my attempts to write this blog perfectly illustrate why. As obvious as a reason may be, until it is pointed out to you, it’s incredibly difficult to recognise it in yourself. The people who need this course the most are the ones who will say, ”well yes, that’s what most people might do, but I’d never do that” when we discuss an incident and why it happened.
It took a long conversation with a close friend about my frustrations of trying to write this for me to see what I was doing. A lot of people have heard of the Dunning-Kruger effect. This is where someone with little knowledge of a subject believes they have far more knowledge than they do. It’s proved time and again when divers start a course many think it will be easy, after all, all you have to do is put the breathey thing in your mouth and swim, right?! The interesting thing that Dunning and Kruger found was that at the other end of the scale, experts believe that they don’t know anything. Because they understand the scope of the subject, they’ve learned that they’ve only just scraped the surface of it, after all, it’s impossible for even the world’s best experts to know absolutely every single thing there is to know about a subject.
And so here we are. I, as a new instructor, know nothing. Although, I certainly have a good idea of how much more there is to know. So maybe I do know something, after all.